Madame X - A 2023 Reappraisal

Madame X is a stenographer!

  • Total voters
    15
Cerro de Casa

Cerro de Casa

User
Joined
Feb 3, 2004
Messages
68,342
How do we feel about this album 3.5 years down the line?
Feels topical.



Deluxe version out now on Spotty Fry
 
I agree.

1980s - Like A Prayer
1990s - Ray Of Light
2000s - Confessions On A Dance Floor
2010s - Madame X


I know the 2010s are slim pickings but at least it is a proper album in that sense. Rebel Heart could have been her definitive work of the '10s had the leaks not happened but we've only been over this 389 times so I'll spare you.
 
10 Medellín
09 Dark Ballet
11 God Control
08 Future
09 Batuka
04 Killers Who Are Partying
10 Crave
05 Crazy
08 Come Alive
09 Extreme Occident
09 Faz Gostoso
06 Bitch I'm Loca
10 I Don't Search I Find
08 Looking For Mercy
08 I Rise
06 Funana
07 Back That Up To The Beat
06 Ciao Bella
 
There are some dips but I can easily listen and RELISTEN to the whole thing gladly. It's an 8 or a 9 overall and I'm feeling generous today.

Some of the visuals were pretty sleek this campaign but some were horrible. :D
 
Tisch said:
There are some dips but I can easily listen and RELISTEN to the whole thing gladly. It's an 8 or a 9 overall and I'm feeling generous today.

Some of the visuals were pretty sleek this campaign but some were horrible. :D
Click to expand...
OMG Madame X is Relistenable

I don't think anyone's ever quite described it that way before.

(If you know the two references you know)
 
Tisch said:
There are some dips
Click to expand...


1673605319445.png
 
I think I understand why people get a gun
I think I understand why we all give up
Every day they have a kind of victory
Blood of innocents, spread everywhere

They say that we need love
But we need more than this

BackSizzlingHamster-size_restricted.gif
 
Marilyn said:
I think I understand why people get a gun
I think I understand why we all give up
Every day they have a kind of victory
Blood of innocents, spread everywhere

They say that we need love
But we need more than this

BackSizzlingHamster-size_restricted.gif
Click to expand...
I love the bits with the distorted vocals on this track and was disappointed that she didn’t write those particular lyrics herself.
 
I do like Madame X on the whole, I think parts of it really showed there is still a genuine creative artist at work. Personally I’d prefer her to have committed harder to integrating Luso cultural sounds throughout the album and have them more to the fore, even on the uptempos, as for me these are the best parts of the album.
 
I really don’t like it.

Medellin is amazing. One of her best post-Confessions tracks.

I Don’t Search I Find is also very good, the remixes better.

I don’t care at all for anything else so they’re not enough to save it unfortunately.

A dud.
 
Medellín is by far its best song and God Control is pretty good too. I also like a Killers Who Are Partying. however her vox are as bad as they've ever been on many of the songs so it's not something I ever revisit.
 
Yeah it’s the vox for me too. She sounds downright terrible on some of the songs. She hasn’t learnt how to utilise or leverage the change in her voice as she’s gotten older, i Imagine largely due to her stubborn “I’ll write and sing whatever I want” attitude, but the dance styles of today are NOT her forte
 
I like it I guess, but when I want to listen to Madonna, I would never go for anything post 2010
 
RJN said:
I like it I guess, but when I want to listen to Madonna, I would never go for anything post 2010
Click to expand...
Madame X is the first of her post 2010 albums I'd choose to play. I very much agree with @BoysForSeles in that I'd have liked her to have leaned into elements of it a lot more.

And I do think parts of the tour looked absolutely beautiful.
 
I remember I kept God Control and I Don't Search (as well as the great lost single FAZ GOSTOSO), never cared much for Medellin :shock:
 
Some songs might technically be alright but as mentioned above, I can’t stand her voice/way of singing anymore.
 
So 3 years, hu Sue (pronounced sway)? Now that the fillers have settled and I've inhaled the beauty of the dance-distilled gems such as Ciao Bella and I Don't Search I Find to the point of overdosing, I proudly give this album an 8 (grade A).
 
I put this on this morning and I realised it's actually REALLY QUITE GOOD. Yes, there's some silly filler, but it's probably an 8. The opening three tracks are all really very good, and I think God Control might actually have been upgraded to the 10/10 I thought it was lacking a few months ago.

Like its predecessor, it would probably have been better with a bit of trimming, off the deluxe edition at least...
 
In my head it's a strong 7. Might revisit when I'm Tensioned out.
 
lolly said:
In my head it's a strong 7. Might revisit when I'm Tensioned out.
Click to expand...

Oh INDEED, I want it noted that it only followed two spins of Tension (and an Alexis Strum). I KNOW ITS PLACE.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 2 (members: 0, guests: 2)
Back
Top Bottom